Monday, February 11, 2008

Judaism (response 1)

I'm going to say that Judaism is a little bit of all three. The term can be used to mean a religion, a culture, or a race, or any combination thereof, so it must be inferred from the context what someone means.Yes, it is a religion, and it is implied therefore that in order to be Jewish one must practice, or at least believe in the religious tenets of Judaism. However, in God's covenant with Abraham, He said "I will establish my covenant between me and you, and your offspring after you throughout their generations, for an everlasting covenant, to be God to you and to your offspring after you." That was really long and redundant, but the point is clear: God's covenant is hereditary. Whether or not they believe it, according to this story, all the descendants of Isaac are JEWISH. Regardless of their beliefs, the people who are descended from Isaac are racially Jewish. I think Judaism is definitely a culture too, though not as easily defined. If someone chooses to identify as being Jewish because he was raised in a culturally Jewish household, that makes perfect sense to me. If someone is adopted into an Italian family, is he not culturally Italian? Jews have customs and traditions and language like any other ethnic group, so I don't see any reason why they should be considered different. Religion is implied but not necessary, as Hispanic families are often Catholic, and Afghan families are often Muslim. If you're bothered by the religious implications of the word "Jewish," then call them Israelites.

3 comments:

francesca said...

I liked that you recognized "implied" traits of cultures, and made the distinction between being practicing and being culturally Jewish. I think it's really interesting because I feel that supporters of Judaism as a race would disagree with you, but I myself agree.

Ms. Snyder said...

I think we need to be careful with the distinction between 'race' and 'ethnicity.' Race implies genetic traits that are passed down through generations, while ethnicity is how you define your cultural heritage (Irish, Polish, Italian, etc). Modern genetics point to the artificiality of race, since genetic differences are minimal between what many consider as 'races.' I think ethnicity is the more appropriate term for Judiasm, as it allows for hereditary transmission of culture while also allowing for differences in skin color, eye color, hair texture, and geographic place of origin.

Anonymous said...

Good point about ethnicity vs. race -- if you think about it, the term "race" is comparable to "Judaism," in that it's almost impossible to define. What race is someone who is half black, or half Asian? What about someone who's 1/8 black? Where do you draw the line? With that taken into consideration, I would say that Judaism is more of an ethnicity than a race.