Monday, February 11, 2008
Judaism: Religion v. Culture
Although Judaism can be defined in many ways, it seems appropriate that it should be primarily defined as a religion; or, I should say, as primarily a non-Jew but also as an atheist, I see Judaism as mostly a religion because firstly, in the historical context, people first identified with Judaism when God spoke to Moses on Mt. Sinai—this focus on God, and the fact the primary source for this history is the Bible, suggests to me that Judaism is based on religion. Secondly, although according to Jewish law, one is not Jewish unless descended from Jewish parents (mothers), historical Jews, who were first the Israelites, came from a multitude of nations and empires of different peoples. Similarly, today religion, culture and race are all aspects of determining nationality—yet modern Jews are part of many different nations as are individuals who identify with other religions. Practices in Judaism are all elements of religious expression, and although one can be born Jewish—according to Jewish law primarily recoded in the Torah—the fact that this is based on religious law should not be overlooked by the fact that Judaism can be inherited.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
These are some valid points. It's true that Judaism can be most clearly defined as a religion, but I also think that the fact that it is a hereditary religion makes it unique. It's a religion with a significant cultural and racial base.
This is true- Religion and culture are similar in that one major item of cultural identiy is relgious preference- many relgions similarily have cultural bases. However, it is possible to find cultures that are dispersed in religious preferences, and diferent cultures wiht similar religions. I think that the fact that Judaism is hereditary becomes complicated when we speak of religion as a race, not culture. I think that it is always tricky to seperate individuals based on race, especially when the other principals of that particular group are based on personal belief- religion.
Post a Comment